Italian · New York City, NY

Carmenta's

50 Starr Street

Last inspected Sep 2, 2025 · View Map ↗ · Compare ↗

Read Reviews on Google

A Grade

Get the Next Inspection, Free.

We'll email you when Carmenta's has a new health inspection. No spam, one-click unsubscribe.

Own this restaurant? Add an Inspection Badge to Your Website · Inspection Prep Checklist

SteadyThe last two inspections recorded a similar number of violations. Review the dated records below.

Quick Answers

When was Carmenta's last inspected?: The most recent inspection on record was on Sep 2, 2025. The result listed by NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene was “Grade A” (official score 2).
Were any violations recorded at the last inspection?: Yes: 1 violation recorded, none marked critical. Each one is listed below with the official wording.
How many inspections are on record?: 2 inspections on record, from Oct 4, 2023 to Sep 2, 2025.
Has Carmenta's ever been closed by the health department?: No closure appears in the 2 inspection records we hold for this business. The earliest is dated Oct 4, 2023.

The Full Inspection History

2 inspections

Cycle Inspection / Initial Inspection

Sep 2, 2025

A Grade

Official score: 2 · Understand This Area’s Scale

1 recorded violation

minorCode 10FCleaning and sanitizing

Official Wording

Non-food contact surface or equipment made of unacceptable material, not kept clean, or not properly sealed, raised, spaced or movable to allow accessibility for cleaning on all sides, above and underneath the unit.

In Plain English

Dishes, equipment, or surfaces that touch food were not properly washed, rinsed, and sanitized, or sanitizer was not at the right strength. Clean surfaces help stop germs from spreading to food.

More about cleaning or sanitizing problems

Official record from NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, Sep 2, 2025 · Original Source

Cycle Inspection / Initial Inspection

Oct 4, 2023

A Grade

Official score: 2 · Understand This Area’s Scale

1 recorded violation

minorCode 10FCleaning and sanitizing

Official Wording

In Plain English

Dishes, equipment, or surfaces that touch food were not properly washed, rinsed, and sanitized, or sanitizer was not at the right strength. Clean surfaces help stop germs from spreading to food.

More about cleaning or sanitizing problems

Official record from NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, Oct 4, 2023 · Original Source

More Restaurants Nearby

A Grade

Leslie's Kitchen

Brooklyn · New York City, NY·Tex-Mex

Sep 18, 20251 recorded violation

A Grade

Fukurou Brooklyn

Brooklyn · New York City, NY·Japanese

Oct 26, 20263 recorded violations

A Grade

101 Wilson Bar

Brooklyn · New York City, NY·American

Mar 28, 20262 recorded violations

A Grade

Ic Brooklyn Cafe

Brooklyn · New York City, NY·Coffee/Tea

Oct 8, 20252 recorded violations

All restaurants in ZIP 11221